Tony'S Coffee

Tony's Coffee, Cafe Carmelita

Tony's Coffee, Cafe Carmelita (12oz), Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Organic and Fair Trade

8.8 /10
★★★★½ Highly Recommended Overall Score · 80% expert / 20% community Ranked #397 of 1193 (Top 34%)
Our Coffee Score 8.7
Coffee Lovers Score 9.1
Overall Ranked #397 of 1193 (Top 34%)
Coffee Beans Ranked #104 of 200 (Top 52%)
Our Coffee Score Ranked #424 of 1193 (Top 36%)
Coffee Lovers Ranked #496 of 1193 (Top 42%)

Our verdict: Ranked #101 of our top 200 coffee beans — an outstanding medium pick, earning a 4.6★ average across 151 Amazon ratings.

BrewRank is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission — it never affects a score.

Key facts

Roast
Medium
Origin
Multi-region blend
Process
Organic
Size
12 oz
Best for
Drip

Flavor notes

The Coffee Score review

Tony's Coffee, Cafe Carmelita (12oz), Medium Roast Whole Bean Coffee, Organic and Fair Trade Our team spent hands-on time with the Tony's Coffee, Cafe Carmelita to see how it holds up against the rest of the coffee beans we've tested.

Across repeated sessions we evaluated it on the categories that matter most: quality, consistency, value, and how likely we are to reach for it again. Ranked #101 of our top 200 coffee beans — an outstanding medium pick, earning a 4.6★ average across 151 Amazon ratings.

From the roaster

  • Breakfast

What we liked

  • Strong overall Coffee Score of 8.7/10 — ranked #397 of 1193 (34% percentile).
  • Distinct flavor profile: .
  • Community agrees — a Coffee Lovers Score of 9.1/10 from 151 ratings.

How we graded this coffee

Grading framework
Taste 40% weight 8.7
Freshness 20% weight 9.3
Bean Quality & Sourcing 15% weight 9.1
Value 15% weight 7.6
Roast Quality 10% weight 9
Our Coffee Score (experts, 80% of overall) 8.7/10

The Coffee Lovers Score

Averages 4.6★ from 151 verified Amazon shoppers.

5 star 82%
4 star 9%
3 star 4%
2 star 2%
1 star 3%
  • MrsB Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Organic Fair Trade for the WIN!

    Tony's never fails and cafe carmelita has to be one of the top 5 I've had. What would only be better is if they sold the green beans so I could roast it fresh. I prefer to esprrsso grind this, pull 2 double shots and have it over ice. However it is an excellent cold brew.

  • Teeise Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Delicious

    Delicious coffee. In the past we purchased Tony’s Espresso Classico whole bean, but since this was unavailable, we took a chance on buying Cafe Carmelita. I must say that the Cafe Carmelita is every bit as good as the Espresso Classico. Tony’s coffee is just a wonderful product.

    1 found this helpful

  • Gin Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Great coffee

    Great tasting fresh coffee. Tony's is my new go to coffee company.

  • 3rd Day Believer Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Tops: Smooth + chocolate-y / Will likely please everybody

    Can't go wrong with this coffee. Can be hard to find. Trying this has driven me to try other blends from Tony's. Ordered the decaf whole-bean version of this Carmelta. Keeping my fingers crossed on that one. Outstanding roast—and possibly the one coffee that will please just about everybody.

Read all 151 reviews on Amazon