Amazon's ChoiceGreat Value

Cafe Don Pablo

5LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo

Mild, sweet, and rich with a very smooth cocoa toned finish

9.5 /10
★★★★★ Must Drink Overall Score · 80% expert / 20% community Ranked #5 of 1193 (Top 1%)
Our Coffee Score 9.5
Coffee Lovers Score 9.3
Overall Ranked #5 of 1193 (Top 1%)
Coffee Beans Ranked #2 of 200 (Top 1%)
Our Coffee Score Ranked #5 of 1193 (Top 1%)
Coffee Lovers Ranked #210 of 1193 (Top 18%)

Our verdict: Ranked #2 of our top 200 coffee beans — an outstanding medium-dark pick with cocoa, smooth, sweet notes, earning a 4.7★ average across 678 Amazon ratings.

BrewRank is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission — it never affects a score.

Key facts

Roast
Medium-Dark
Origin
Colombia
Process
Roasted
Size
80 oz
Price / oz
$0.84
Best for
Drip

Flavor notes

CocoaSmoothSweetRich

The Coffee Score review

Mild, sweet, and rich with a very smooth cocoa toned finish Our team spent hands-on time with the 5LB Don Pablo Colombian Supremo to see how it holds up against the rest of the coffee beans we've tested.

Across repeated sessions we evaluated it on the categories that matter most: quality, consistency, value, and how likely we are to reach for it again. Ranked #2 of our top 200 coffee beans — an outstanding medium-dark pick with cocoa, smooth, sweet notes, earning a 4.7★ average across 678 Amazon ratings.

From the roaster

  • Mild, sweet, and rich with a very smooth cocoa toned finish
  • 5Lb Bag - Medium-Dark roast - Whole bean Arabica coffee - GMO Free
  • Medium bodied with low acidity
  • Artisan Roasted in Small Batches for Optimum Freshness

What we liked

  • Strong overall Coffee Score of 9.5/10 — ranked #5 of 1193 (1% percentile).
  • Distinct flavor profile: Cocoa, Smooth, Sweet, Rich.
  • Community agrees — a Coffee Lovers Score of 9.3/10 from 678 ratings.

How we graded this coffee

Small-batch / craft roaster Grading framework
Taste 40% weight 9.8
Freshness 20% weight 9.7
Bean Quality & Sourcing 15% weight 10
Value 15% weight 8.1
Roast Quality 10% weight 9.6
Our Coffee Score (experts, 80% of overall) 9.5/10

The Coffee Lovers Score

Averages 4.7★ from 678 verified Amazon shoppers.

5 star 82%
4 star 11%
3 star 5%
2 star 1%
1 star 1%
  • Adam Kovynia Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Value and Quality

    I recommend Don Pablo's Columbian Coffee because when you compare the cost with other good quality coffee's it is a much better value ( even half the cost or less ) plus it is free shipping on amazon. The smell, taste, and look are all excellent.

    1 found this helpful

  • Jeff Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Best Coffee I ever had

    Backstory: been out of coffee for a few days. Tired of trying to find whole bean coffee at the grocer. They only carry ground swill and Kcups. I like coffee freshly ground when brewed.I came home from work and found this had been delivered today. I opened the bag and WOW, what a smell!

    5 found this helpful

  • Christian Stclaire Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Great flavor

    One of the best coffee I have ever bought, I mix both Italian Expresso with this Columbian Supremo for a great resultHighly recommend.

  • steven napier Verified purchase ★★★★★

    You Must Try This!

    The absolute BEST coffee PERIOD. Nuff said!

Read all 678 reviews on Amazon