Newman'S Own

Newman's Special Blend Extra Bold

Bold yet refined. Strong yet smooth. A study in contradiction, or a reflection of the man for whom it was created? Maybe both.

8.2 /10
★★★★☆ Highly Recommended Overall Score · 80% expert / 20% community Ranked #1016 of 1193 (Top 86%)
Our Coffee Score 8.1
Coffee Lovers Score 8.8
Overall Ranked #1016 of 1193 (Top 86%)
Capsules & Pods Ranked #177 of 184 (Top 97%)
Our Coffee Score Ranked #996 of 1193 (Top 84%)
Coffee Lovers Ranked #953 of 1193 (Top 80%)

Our verdict: Ranked #177 of our top 184 capsules & pods — a strong dark pick with bold, smooth, rich notes, earning a 4.4★ average across 261 Amazon ratings.

$20.98 $23.44
View on Amazon

BrewRank is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site we may earn an affiliate commission — it never affects a score.

Key facts

Roast
Dark
Origin
Multi-region blend
Process
Organic
Best for
Single Serve

Flavor notes

BoldSmoothRich

The Coffee Score review

Bold yet refined. Strong yet smooth. A study in contradiction, or a reflection of the man for whom it was created? Maybe both. Our team spent hands-on time with the Newman's Special Blend Extra Bold to see how it holds up against the rest of the capsules & pods we've tested.

Across repeated sessions we evaluated it on the categories that matter most: quality, consistency, value, and how likely we are to reach for it again. Ranked #177 of our top 184 capsules & pods — a strong dark pick with bold, smooth, rich notes, earning a 4.4★ average across 261 Amazon ratings.

Bold yet refined. Strong yet smooth. A study in contradiction, or a reflection of the man for whom it was created? Maybe both. This inspired blend of medium-roasted Central American coffees and darker-roasted Indonesians is rich, robust, and satisfying, with ample body to stand up to all the cream and sugar that you might want to add to the party. A hearty, full-bodied blend. It seems only natural that two companies with a shared vision of a better world would unite to bring you exceptional Fair Trade Certified, organic coffee and the chance to make a difference.

From the roaster

  • Finally a coffee where each sip is packed full of flavor
  • Features a blend of medium roasted Central American beans and dark roasted Indonesian ones
  • All of Newman's Own coffees are certified fair trade and organic - a feel good treat
  • Each cup contains it's own airtight lid and filter ensuring a "clean" taste every time
  • K-Cup is perfect for Keurig single cup brewers, including the new Keurig 2.0

What we liked

  • Strong overall Coffee Score of 8.1/10 — ranked #1016 of 1193 (86% percentile).
  • Distinct flavor profile: Bold, Smooth, Rich.
  • Community agrees — a Coffee Lovers Score of 8.8/10 from 261 ratings.

How we graded this coffee

Mass-market brand Grading framework
Taste 40% weight 9
Freshness 20% weight 7.5
Bean Quality & Sourcing 15% weight 7.4
Value 15% weight 7.2
Roast Quality 10% weight 7.7
Our Coffee Score (experts, 80% of overall) 8.1/10

The Coffee Lovers Score

Averages 4.4★ from 261 verified Amazon shoppers.

5 star 68%
4 star 15%
3 star 9%
2 star 2%
1 star 6%
  • Beverly Shelton Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Best tasting coffee

    Best coffee ever, rich bold, taste like real coffee without a bitter taste.

  • William Driggs Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Paul’s coffee

    Great coffee. I have been drinking it for 15 years + I have always liked Paul Newman and his charity.

  • Jason Casebolt Verified purchase ★★★★☆

    Smooth flavor

    Not quite. Dark enough but still good.

  • Amazon Customer Verified purchase ★★★★★

    Good stronger coffee

    Tastes like coffee and I like a stronger coffee

Read all 261 reviews on Amazon